Building Trust in Local Journalism Through Honest Conversations
Strong local journalism depends on more than accurate reporting. It also depends on the relationships journalists build, the voices they include, and their willingness to ask difficult questions. For Baltimore journalist and author D Watkins, meaningful journalism begins with recognizing that no single person has every answer and that communities have valuable knowledge to contribute.
This article draws on an episode of Five Dubs, a podcast of MDDC Press Association exploring local news media and the people, businesses, and communities connected to it. Host Rebecca Snyder speaks with D Watkins, a Baltimore author, journalist, and educator originally from East Baltimore. His work spans books, television, personal essays, and magazine journalism, including contributions to The Atlantic, Esquire, and The New York Times Magazine. A professor at the University of Baltimore, Watkins is bringing his storytelling experience to public radio as host of The Engagement, a new program on WYPR and Baltimore Public Media. The full conversation is available on Five Dubs on Spotify.
Journalism Needs Conversations, Not Just Clicks
Watkins sees a fundamental challenge in how journalism measures success. Reporters face pressure to publish quickly, break stories first, and attract clicks, while the depth of their reporting and its impact on communities may receive less attention.
His approach places greater value on research, meaningful conversations, and the perspectives that emerge when journalists spend time understanding the people behind a story.
That philosophy shapes The Engagement, which debuted October 19 on WYPR. The program uses a magazine-style format that combines reporting, interviews, and community participation. Watkins wants listeners to have opportunities to engage directly with the people featured in stories, ask questions, and contribute their own experiences.
Rather than treating audiences solely as consumers of information, the format gives them a role in shaping conversations. For local news organizations, the approach raises an important consideration: meaningful engagement can involve more than measuring how many people encounter a story.
Building Community Trust Takes Time
Trust is central to Watkins’ approach to journalism, particularly when working with people who may be hesitant to share personal experiences.
He believes journalists should avoid treating relationships with sources as transactions. Instead of approaching someone solely because their experience could strengthen a story, journalists can establish that they are available, interested, and willing to listen without demanding agreement or participation.
Watkins recognizes that some people may not feel comfortable sharing their experiences immediately. In those situations, trust may need to develop over time.
His perspective comes partly from a difficult reporting experience involving a Maryland worker who described racial discrimination in the workplace. Watkins spent two years pursuing the story, but the publication ultimately declined to run it.
The experience stayed with him because the source had taken a significant emotional risk by sharing what happened. Watkins understood how difficult it had been for the worker to recount the experience and felt the weight of being unable to bring the story to publication.
The situation illustrates an important responsibility in journalism. Sources may share deeply personal experiences that carry emotional and professional consequences, making the relationship between reporter and source an essential part of the reporting process.
Better Reporting Begins With Listening
Watkins traces part of his understanding of storytelling to childhood experiences accompanying his father to Narcotics Anonymous meetings.
As a young observer, he listened to people share difficult experiences in a setting where others understood many of their struggles. Looking back, he recognizes those meetings as an early education in layered storytelling, emotional honesty, and the importance of listening.
Those lessons continue to influence his approach to interviews.
Watkins describes himself as a lifelong student who values opportunities to discover what he does not know. He approaches conversations with curiosity rather than assuming he already understands another person’s experience.
That openness also informs his approach to selecting guests for The Engagement. While he values academic and professional expertise, he believes people directly affected by an issue offer knowledge that cannot always be captured through an expert’s broader perspective.
The program aims to bring those perspectives together. Conversations about utility costs, environmental concerns, politics, and everyday life can include both people who study an issue and those who experience its consequences.
For journalists, this approach reinforces the value of reporting that combines verified information with firsthand community experiences.
Accountability and Respect Can Work Together
Creating space for different perspectives does not mean avoiding difficult questions.
Watkins intends to challenge guests when their answers fail to address the questions being asked. At the same time, he wants conversations to remain respectful rather than confrontational for their own sake.
He recognizes that experienced interview subjects may rely on rehearsed responses or redirect difficult questions. His approach is to acknowledge when an answer falls short and continue pursuing a more meaningful exchange.
Preparation remains important. Watkins and his production team develop questions before interviews, but he also allows conversations to move in unexpected directions when a guest reveals something worth exploring.
That flexibility reflects his broader approach to storytelling. Whether writing or interviewing, Watkins sees value in allowing new information to challenge initial assumptions.
The result he hopes to achieve is not simply a collection of opposing viewpoints, but a fuller understanding of complicated issues.
What This Means for Local News
Watkins’ approach offers a useful perspective on the relationship between journalism and the communities it serves.
Accurate reporting remains essential, but the process of gathering information also matters. Taking time to develop relationships, welcoming perspectives beyond traditional experts, and remaining open to unexpected answers can deepen the stories journalists tell.
His vision for The Engagement is a public forum where people can share knowledge, challenge assumptions, and better understand the experiences of their neighbors.
For local journalism, the underlying principle is straightforward: community trust grows through sustained relationships, careful listening, and a willingness to pursue difficult conversations with integrity.
Those practices help make journalism more responsive to the people whose lives and communities it covers.
The Engagement airs Monday through Thursday from 11 a.m. to noon on WYPR 88.1 FM.
Want to learn more?
Listen to the full episode of the MDDC Press Association Podcast by CLICKING HERE.
This blog post was written with the assistance of AI.
Recent Posts











