Press Freedom Is Stronger When the News Industry Stands Together
Congressman Jamie Raskin on government pressure, institutional independence and why protecting press access matters to newsrooms of every size.
Press freedom is often discussed as a constitutional principle, but its strength also depends on how journalists and news organizations respond when that freedom is challenged. For Congressman Jamie Raskin, recent confrontations over press access offer an important lesson about the relationship between government authority, independent institutions and the collective responsibility to protect fundamental freedoms.
This article draws on an episode of Five Dubs, a podcast of MDDC Press Association exploring local news media and the people, businesses and communities connected to it. In this conversation, Rebecca Snyder speaks with Congressman Jamie Raskin, who represents Maryland in the U.S. House of Representatives. Raskin is also the author of We the Students, a book he discussed in connection with restrictions on its use in Texas schools. His experience as a lawmaker and author provides a perspective on constitutional freedoms, government authority and the importance of defending independent institutions. Listen to Five Dubs on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0eqPC0EYwkiEm4uvZsxEAl?si=3c0a3df349f14a49.
A Common Defense Across Competing News Organizations
During the conversation, Raskin addressed a recent dispute involving restrictions on press pool coverage. Rather than focusing exclusively on the immediate controversy, he emphasized what the response revealed about the news industry’s ability to defend its shared interests.
Raskin described the situation as evidence that the press was under attack, but he also identified an encouraging development: news organizations with different audiences, editorial perspectives and political orientations were standing together.
He pointed specifically to CNN, MSNBC and Fox as examples of organizations participating in a common response. For outlets that compete intensely for audiences and frequently approach political coverage from different perspectives, that unity carried particular significance.
Raskin characterized solidarity across media organizations and political differences as “a recipe for victory.” His observation underscored an important distinction: competing vigorously in the marketplace of ideas does not prevent news organizations from cooperating when their ability to report independently is threatened.
Press Freedom and the Exercise of Government Power
The discussion also raised broader questions about the relationship between government authority and independent institutions. Raskin connected the dispute over press access to actions taken against major law firms, describing executive orders that restricted security access, federal contracting opportunities, federal employment and access to federal buildings.
He noted the practical consequences of those restrictions, particularly for attorneys whose work requires access to federal courthouses. The example illustrated how government actions can affect an institution’s ability to carry out its professional responsibilities, even without directly prohibiting the work itself.
Although journalism and legal practice serve different functions, Raskin’s comparison placed the press access controversy within a wider discussion about institutional independence. His concern extended beyond any particular media outlet or dispute with the administration to the potential consequences of using government authority against independent professions.
What Washington’s Press Access Battles Mean for Local News
The dispute Raskin described involved national news organizations, but the underlying question is familiar to local journalists: who gets access to the information necessary to hold government accountable?
For a reporter covering a county council in Maryland, a school board in Delaware or a municipal government in Washington, D.C., access is not an abstract constitutional concern. It determines whether journalists can attend public meetings, question officials, obtain government records and independently verify decisions that affect residents.
The stakes can be particularly high for smaller newsrooms. A national network may have attorneys, dedicated government affairs staff and substantial resources to challenge restrictions. A community newspaper or independent digital publication may have only a handful of journalists, making the time and expense of fighting for access a significant burden.
Consider a local government that limits which outlets can attend a briefing, provides information only to selected reporters or makes public records difficult to obtain. Those practices can affect not only the excluded newsroom but also the community’s ability to understand decisions about taxes, schools, development and public spending.
These local examples extend the principles discussed in Raskin’s conversation rather than describing incidents he specifically cited. They illustrate why the defense of press access matters well beyond the White House press corps.
For local publishers and editors, the broader implication is that access disputes should not be viewed solely as another newsroom’s problem. A restriction affecting one outlet can establish expectations that may eventually affect others, regardless of their size, format or editorial perspective.
Defending the Conditions for Independent Journalism
Raskin’s central argument was that the response to government pressure can influence its effectiveness. He viewed the united reaction to the press access dispute as an encouraging example of institutions recognizing a common interest and acting accordingly.
That principle has particular relevance for MDDC Press Association, whose work includes advocating for press freedom, public access and the ability of local journalists to report on government. Whether the issue involves access to public meetings, public records or government officials, the underlying concern is the same: communities depend on journalists being able to gather information without arbitrary interference.
Raskin’s remarks offer a reminder that press freedom is not simply a national issue fought in Washington. It is exercised every day in statehouses, county offices, city halls and school board meetings across Maryland, Delaware and Washington, D.C. Protecting that access is essential to ensuring that local residents have the independent information they need to understand and participate in the decisions shaping their communities.
This blog post was written with the assistance of AI.
Recent Posts











