Investigative Journalism That Makes a Difference: Kate Cimini on Reporting With Purpose
From investigating concerns about the treatment of vulnerable young people to interviewing people who have experienced trauma, The Baltimore Sun's Kate Cimini discusses the persistence, compassion and careful judgment required in investigative journalism.
Investigative journalism can uncover institutional problems, inform public discussion and bring attention to experiences that might otherwise go unheard. But behind every investigation is a reporter navigating incomplete records, conflicting accounts and difficult ethical decisions. For Kate Cimini of The Baltimore Sun, the work is ultimately about helping people while presenting the fairest and most complete picture the available evidence supports.
This article draws on Episode 185 of Five Dubs, a podcast of MDDC Press Association, which explores the people and issues shaping local journalism. Host Rebecca Snyder speaks with Kate Cimini, an investigative editor at The Baltimore Sun whose reporting on Maryland's Free State Challenge Academy received first place in the A-Mark Foundation investigative journalism awards presented through MDDC. A former public school teacher, Cimini began her journalism career freelancing and later reported extensively on agricultural workers in California. Her work reflects a commitment to careful reporting, public service and ethical treatment of sources. Listen to Five Dubs on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/0eqPC0EYwkiEm4uvZsxEAl?si=3c0a3df349f14a49.
An Investigation Begins With a Tip
Cimini's award-winning investigation of Free State Challenge Academy, a National Guard program serving young people who had left high school, began with a tip about possible mistreatment of cadets.
As she investigated, Cimini filed public records requests, reviewed institutional reports and searched for former participants and their families. One particularly important source emerged from an unexpected place: a Google review written by a cadet's father.
That review led her to Nathaniel, a young man who had enrolled in the program hoping to earn his GED and find a path forward after struggling in traditional school.
Nathaniel described a nighttime assault at the academy in which he was struck in the head with a makeshift weapon. Cimini explained that he could not recall every detail of the incident. His family subsequently sought medical care, and the experience became central to her reporting.
The investigation required Cimini to examine more than one troubling account. She sought other cadets' perspectives, reviewed available records and considered the experiences of participants who said the program had helped them.
The academy subsequently closed, but Cimini was careful not to claim that her reporting caused the closure. She discussed facility problems and federal funding decisions while acknowledging that she could not establish what influence, if any, her reporting had on the outcome.
That distinction reflects a fundamental responsibility of investigative journalism: establish what the evidence demonstrates without claiming more than it supports.
The Discipline Behind Long-Term Investigations
Investigations rarely proceed in a straight line. Records requests may take months, sources may be difficult to locate, and reporters often juggle several projects simultaneously.
Cimini described maintaining a running list of investigations, with short summaries to preserve the central questions behind each story. For more complicated projects, she has also begun keeping a reporting diary.
After interviews or reporting sessions, she records what she learned, which details stood out and what questions still need answers. The practice helps her return to an investigation after long delays without having to reconstruct every earlier step.
She also emphasized the importance of evaluating tips carefully. Although The Baltimore Sun receives a large volume of messages through its tip channels, many are spam or unrelated to original reporting. Cimini looks more closely at submissions that present specific concerns and offer a credible starting point for further investigation.
The most promising investigations, she explained, are often those involving pressing problems and the potential for meaningful change.
Reporting on Trauma Without Causing More Harm
One of the conversation's most valuable discussions concerned how journalists interview people who have experienced trauma.
Cimini said she frequently speaks with sources about some of the most painful experiences of their lives. Before interviewing them, she explains that published accounts may remain online for decades and could be read later by family members, employers or others.
Her goal is to help sources understand the possible consequences of participating before they decide how much to share.
In Nathaniel's case, although he was an adult when interviewed, Cimini asked that a parent be present because the experience she was documenting had occurred when he was younger. She also made clear that he did not have to answer questions he was uncomfortable discussing.
Her approach reflects an understanding that obtaining a compelling interview is not the only measure of responsible reporting. Journalists must also consider the lasting effects of publication on people who have already experienced harm.
Cimini described her responsibility as helping people without putting those who have already been victimized in a worse situation. That commitment informs both her reporting methods and her relationships with sources.
Fairness Means Acknowledging Complicated Realities
Investigative stories often reveal serious problems, but Cimini cautioned against reducing complicated situations to simple narratives.
Some young people reported positive experiences at Free State Challenge Academy, even as others described troubling conditions. Its closure also meant the loss of a program that some participants valued, along with employment for people who worked there.
Cimini acknowledged that reporting cannot capture every perspective, but she believes journalists must make a serious effort to represent the complexity they can document.
That commitment to fairness does not diminish the importance of examining potential wrongdoing. Instead, it strengthens reporting by helping readers understand the broader circumstances and consequences of the facts uncovered.
Measuring Impact One Person at a Time
Cimini's previous reporting in California demonstrates the different ways journalism can make a difference.
During the COVID-19 pandemic, she worked with a colleague to investigate conditions affecting agricultural workers. Their reporting examined workplace protections, illness and the challenges facing workers in crowded living conditions. Cimini described subsequent changes to state requirements addressing worker health and safety.
Yet one of the stories that affected her most deeply involved a terminally ill community activist who was struggling to raise money for her funeral. Cimini spent time getting to know the woman and her family and documenting her life and circumstances. Following publication, the family received enough support to cover the funeral, and arrangements were made for the woman to be buried beside her son.
For Cimini, that individual outcome was as meaningful as broader changes resulting from investigative reporting.
Her perspective offers an important reminder for local newsrooms across Maryland, Delaware and Washington, D.C. Investigative journalism is not defined solely by the size of an institution examined or the number of people affected. It can also help a family find answers, give a vulnerable person a voice or make a meaningful difference in one person's life.
As Cimini continues her work at The Baltimore Sun, her ambition is to contribute to Baltimore's tradition of consequential journalism. The measure of success she returns to is whether the reporting helps people and improves their lives.
This blog post was written with the assistance of AI.
Recent Posts











