The Best Media Pitch Starts With Knowing the Community
A press release can announce a new leader, describe a promising program or introduce an expert. But whether that information becomes journalism depends on something more fundamental: its relevance to a publication’s readers. For public relations professionals working with local newsrooms, understanding that distinction can make the difference between a useful relationship and another overlooked email.
This article draws on an episode of Five Dubs, a podcast of MDDC Press Association exploring local news media and the communities connected to it. Moderator Rebecca Snyder speaks with three editors: Alexis Taylor, managing editor of The AFRO News, who began writing for the publication as an intern in 2011; Marcus Dieterle, managing editor of Baltimore Fishbowl and a former editor at the Cecil Whig; and Sameer Rao, who joined The Daily Record after editing Technical.ly’s Baltimore and Washington coverage. Their discussion examines what makes earned-media outreach valuable. Listen to the full conversation: https://open.spotify.com/show/0eqPC0EYwkiEm4uvZsxEAl?si=3c0a3df349f14a49.
Know the Audience Before Making the Pitch
The three publications serve different communities and approach news through different lenses. Baltimore Fishbowl mixes politics, education and regional reporting with culture and lifestyle coverage. The Daily Record focuses on Maryland’s legal, legislative and business communities. The AFRO centers news relevant to Black communities, from policy and health to neighborhood resources and the experiences of people often overlooked elsewhere.
Dieterle emphasized that effective outreach requires more than a quick glance at a publication’s website. Public relations professionals should understand both what an outlet covers and how it covers those subjects. Rao agreed that the same underlying development may merit distinct angles for different audiences, while cautioning that a purported exclusive should not simultaneously be offered to competitors.
Offer Time, Access and Useful Sources
Taylor described the practical value of embargoed announcements for a small newsroom. Advance notice gives editors time to plan coverage and compete with larger organizations without learning about important developments only after they become public. She also welcomed proactive lists of available experts tied to timely subjects, such as health awareness campaigns, because they help reporters identify credible sources before deadlines become urgent.
Dieterle likewise encouraged ongoing relationships rather than outreach limited to major announcements. An expert who is not right for today’s article may become valuable when another story emerges. The discussion also acknowledged that this consideration works both ways: reporters seeking interviews, especially with busy clinicians, can improve their chances by providing reasonable lead time when the news is not breaking.
A Pitch Is the Beginning, Not the Finished Story
Editors do not simply reproduce the narrative offered by a public relations representative. Taylor described receiving a proposal to interview a doctor already featured in a Word in Black series about transplants. Rather than duplicate that reporting, The AFRO pursued a different angle on a program connecting Georgia historically Black colleges and universities with medical professionals. The result offered readers something new while still examining the initiative the source hoped to highlight.
Rao explained that a submission may fit a special publication, recognition program or future source list even when it cannot become a daily news story. He also distinguished editorial coverage from paid placement, an important option when the primary objective is to control a promotional message. Taylor made a similar distinction when discussing leadership announcements that lack a broader community impact.
Bring the People Affected Into the Story
The editors returned repeatedly to whose voices appear in coverage. Taylor described following up on Baltimore food-assistance funding by speaking with organizations responsible for delivering support and examining how resources reached residents. A story about a youth program, she argued, should include young people who actually experience it, not only the officials announcing it.
Rao identified underreported stories in smaller economic sectors and communities outside Maryland’s central population corridor. Dieterle urged journalists to seek fresh perspectives alongside established institutional sources. For public relations professionals, the implication is concrete: access to people doing the work, receiving services or experiencing a policy can be as useful as access to an executive.
The conversation underscored that local journalism is built around communities, not simply announcements. Strong relationships between communicators and newsrooms respect editorial judgment, recognize limited reporting capacity and make it easier for journalists to tell stories that matter to the people they serve.
This blog post was written with the assistance of AI.
Recent Posts











